
One of these bottles contains 100% Pure Maple Syrup. One of these bottles contains only 4% maple syrup and 96% brown rice syrup. If you read the labels it’s obvious which is which. If you were to remove the labels, however, even a seasoned maple syrup producer could be fooled as to what might be in the bottle of Log Cabin All Natural Syrup. This is undoubtedly what Pinnacle Foods Group LLC, owners of the Log Cabin brand, want the average consumer to believe. This is what all makers of imitation maple syrups have always wanted: to put the idea into the consumer’s mind that their imitation product is the same as the real thing, only less expensive.
By law they can’t say it’s the real thing unless it actually is. Anything labeled “maple syrup” must be 100% Pure Maple. The label “maple flavored”, however, is not nearly as restrictive. For all I know, I could call a gallon of milk “maple flavored” if it sat open in my fridge next to a decanter of my own pure maple syrup – but I wouldn’t want to pour it on my pancakes. You won’t find the term “maple flavored” on a bottle of Log Cabin All Natural Syrup, though. This is probably because they felt it would contradict their claim of ”no artificial flavor”. The term “flavored” evokes images of something added, and additives have the stigma of being unnatural or artificial. The scant 1.5 tablespoons of real maple syrup in this product is undoubtedly pure and natural, but there’s no room for an argumentative essay on a product label. The fewer words, the better, down to and including using no words at all.
And this is exactly how Log Cabin All Natural Syrup intends to win you over – with no words at all. Their persuasive argument to you the consumer is their packaging, and their packaging has always been an attempt at misdirection. Walk past the selection of table syrups at your grocery and tell me how many of them are packaged in clear bottles. All of them (until now). Clear bottles let you see the very maple looking artificially colored product inside. If they can get you to think, at first glance, that their product is the same as the real thing then your next question is simply going to be “Which is cheaper?”, a battle they will always win.
The current packaging for Log Cabin All Natural Syrup is just the next generation in the marketing shell game. They have packaged their product, (which in their defense does not actually claim in words to be maple syrup) into a container whose color, shape and style has ever only been associated with 100% Pure Maple Syrup. I’m not even sure that I can come up with an apt analogy for this move, other than to say that if I were to put iced tea into a Jack Daniels style bottle and gave it a black label with white letters – you’d almost certainly be at the party before you realized that the contents of that bottle aren’t going to help you forget your crappy day. A picture is worth a thousand words, and Log Cabin’s hope is that the mental picture of their product packaging is worth every last one of the thousand words you have ever associated with 100% Pure Maple Syrup. Add to this their paid placement of their product alongside jugs and bottles of the real thing, and their battle for your dollar is effectively won, without saying a single word, or running afoul of any existing law. What Log Cabin has done is genius, but evil genius. To maple producers, it’s just insidious.
Pinnacle Foods is not likely to listen to the concerns of those whose livelihood they’re undercutting, but your local grocery store will. If the major grocery chains receive enough negative press about their role in this duplicity, they will be obliged to make it go away by simply shelving the Log Cabin All Natural Syrup where it belongs – with the rest of the maple flavored table syrups.